Redtrust offers four deployment models: Cloud (SaaS), Cloud MSP, Virtual Appliance, and Physical Appliance (HSM). These models differ in hosting location, operational responsibility, and cryptographic key protection. Choose Cloud or Cloud MSP if you want Redtrust to manage the infrastructure. Consider Virtual Appliance or Physical Appliance (HSM) if you need to host the solution on-premises or meet specific infrastructure and key protection requirements. The deployment model alone does not ensure regulatory compliance.
When adopting a digital certificate management platform, you need to define which users and certificates it will support and select a deployment model that meets your organization’s infrastructure, integration, and security requirements.
This article compares Redtrust’s four deployment models, highlighting their benefits and typical use cases. For an overview of the benefits of centralized certificate management, see our article on centralizing digital certificates.
Redtrust deployment models
Redtrust supports four deployment models: Cloud, Cloud MSP, Virtual Appliance, and Physical Appliance (HSM). The following sections explain how each model works and provide a side-by-side comparison.
Cloud
Cloud is a fully hosted solution operated and maintained by Redtrust. Redtrust manages the underlying infrastructure, maintenance, and updates. You can start using the platform once the initial configuration is complete. Key features include:
- Shared cloud environment
- Managed by Redtrust
- Licensing based on users and certificates
- Fast deployment
- Delivered as a hosted service
When to choose Cloud
Choose Cloud if your organization needs a quick deployment, has limited resources for infrastructure administration, or wants to minimize ongoing maintenance.
Advantages:
- Lower operational complexity
- Faster deployment
- Infrastructure managed by Redtrust
- Reduced demand on internal IT resource
Cloud MSP
Cloud MSP combines cloud infrastructure managed by Redtrust with a dedicated environment and additional administrative and integration capabilities:
- Dedicated environment
- Managed by Redtrust
- Support for multiple administrators
- Integration through the signing API
- Cloud infrastructure
When to choose Cloud MSP
Choose Cloud MSP if your organization needs a dedicated hosted environment, multiple administrators, or signing API integration. It is also suitable for organizations in which several departments manage their own users.
Advantages:
- Dedicated environment
- Support for administrative governance
- Scalability
- Signing API integration
Virtual Appliance
Virtual Appliance runs as a virtual machine within your organization’s infrastructure. Your team controls where it is hosted and is responsible for operating the environment and managing availability.
- On-premises, deployed as a virtual machine
- Managed by the customer
- Integration with Active Directory (AD) or Lightweight Directory Access Protocol (LDAP) directories, plus API integration
When to choose Virtual Appliance
Choose Virtual Appliance if your organization needs to keep the deployment within its own infrastructure and does not require a dedicated physical appliance.
Advantages:
- Control over the hosting environment
- Greater administrative autonomy
- Integration with corporate directories
- Alignment with internal security policies
Physical Appliance (HSM)
Physical Appliance (HSM) uses an on-premises central server with a hardware security module (HSM) to protect private keys and perform cryptographic operations. This provides hardware-based key protection. Confirm the HSM model, firmware version, operating configuration, and applicable FIPS validation before specifying a required assurance level. Where qualified electronic signatures are required, assess the applicable qualified signature creation device (QSCD) requirements separately; FIPS validation alone does not establish QSCD status.
- Dedicated physical appliance at the customer’s site
- Managed by the customer
- Hardware-based key protection using an HSM
- AD/LDAP directory integration and API integration
Choose Physical Appliance (HSM) if your organization requires hardware-based private key protection or needs to integrate with an existing HSM environment. This may be relevant to banking, public administration, and other regulated sectors, depending on their specific requirements.
Deployment model comparison
| Cloud (SaaS) | Cloud MSP | Virtual Appliance | Physical Appliance (HSM) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Server location | Cloud, controlled by Redtrust | Cloud, controlled by Redtrust | On-premises, controlled by the customer | On-premises (hardware), controlled by the customer |
| Licensing model | Users + certificates | Certificates | Certificates | Certificates |
| Integrations | — | Signing API | AD/LDAP + API | AD/LDAP + API |
| Environment management | Redtrust | Redtrust | Customer | Customer |
| More than one administrator | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Environment architecture | Shared | Dedicated | Dedicated | Dedicated (hardware) |
| Cryptographic security | Software | Software | Software | Hardware (FIPS 140-2) |
| Service available online | Yes | Yes | No | No |
Choosing the right deployment model
Use the following questions to narrow down your options. Confirm the final choice against your organization’s integration, operational, and compliance requirements.
Do you want to manage the hosting infrastructure yourself?
- No → Cloud or Cloud MSP
- Yes → Virtual Appliance or Physical Appliance (HSM)
Do you need a dedicated environment?
- Yes → Cloud MSP, Virtual Appliance, or Physical Appliance (HSM)
- No → Cloud
Do you need AD/LDAP directory integration?
- Yes → Virtual Appliance or Physical Appliance (HSM)
- No → Choose based on your remaining hosting and integration requirements
Do you require hardware-based private key protection?
- Yes → Physical Appliance (HSM)
- No → Consider Cloud, Cloud MSP, or Virtual Appliance, subject to your other requirements